Lake Lucina, Jacksonville

Market snapshot

Thirty-three closings were recorded at a median of $278,000 and roughly $194 a square foot. Homes averaged 64 days on market against just 1.1 months of supply, and the median was up about 2% on the year. The source labels it a seller's market with limited data. Scarce inventory and a rising median is a combination that tends to persist.

Market figures above are aggregated community sales data taken from the public community-data index published at the website movewithmomentum.com (an unaffiliated third party), dataset generated 2026-07-13, reflecting sales as of 2026-07-09. Figures are area aggregates, not an appraisal or a valuation of any individual home, and they change as new sales record. HOA dues, CDD fees and property taxes are NOT shown here: the only figures available for them are modelled estimates rather than recorded amounts. Ask Keith Jones Sr for the current recorded numbers before you rely on them.

For context, Duval County as a whole carried a county-wide typical home value (ZHVI) of $297,493 and a county median list price of $308,950, with a county-wide average of 57 days on market and a price-cut share of 24.4%, as of the June 2026 data release. Lake Lucina's $278,000 median sale price runs about $19,500 below the county-wide typical value — roughly 6.6% below county norms — while its 64-day average is about a week slower than the county's 57 days. The more telling figure is the 1.1 months of supply against a county that is, on balance, not nearly this tight; that combination of a below-county median with genuinely scarce inventory is what is pushing the market classification here even with a comparatively small 33-sale sample.

Duval County carried 185 total schools and 23 designated Schools of Excellence in the FLDOE 2024-25 data, with average student learning gains of 56.8% in ELA and 59.4% in math countywide. Confirm the exact school assignment for any Lake Lucina address with Duval County Public Schools directly, since Arlington zoning lines can put two houses on the same street in different attendance zones.

Where it is

Open Lake Lucina in Google Maps

What to check before you buy here

Ask the same questions any mid-century Arlington house deserves: roof age, panel type, plumbing material, and whether the windows have been replaced. Then ask about drainage — being near a lake is an amenity right up until the point where it is a flood zone, and the elevation certificate is what settles it. Get insurance quoted in writing before you waive contingencies.

With 1.1 months of supply, Lake Lucina is trading in a tighter band than almost anywhere else on this site, and that changes buyer behavior: expect multiple offers on the properties that show well, and expect a seller who has little reason to negotiate on price when there is this little competing inventory. If you are buying here, get pre-approved and get the inspection scheduled before you make the offer, not after, because a slow start can cost you the house in a market this thin.

Lake Lucina does not carry a CDD assessment the way the newer planned communities to the south do — confirm that against the county tax record for the specific parcel rather than assuming it, since it is one less line item to budget for relative to Nocatee or St. Johns County new construction. If there is a homeowners association for a given section, get the current dues and any pending special assessment in writing; older, smaller associations sometimes defer maintenance long enough that a new owner inherits the bill.

For an investor, the combination of a below-county median and genuinely scarce supply is a workable setup, but confirm actual achievable rents against comparable Arlington listings rather than a citywide figure, and price the insurance and any deferred maintenance into the return before you commit. And if you are selling into this tight a market but still owe more than a sale will net — job loss, an estate, a divorce — that is a short-sale conversation worth having early. Keith Jones Sr is a state-approved short-sale instructor and has guided Northeast Florida sellers through exactly that scenario for close to three decades.

Being close to the lake itself is worth a closer look street by street rather than as a blanket description of the neighborhood. Some streets sit well above the water, others back directly onto it, and the flood zone designation and insurance premium can differ meaningfully between two houses a few hundred feet apart. Ask for the elevation certificate on the specific address, not a neighborhood-wide assumption, before you finalize a budget or a listing price.

More from Keith Jones Sr

• Search active listings
• What is my home worth?
• Mortgage calculator
• About Keith Jones Sr

Who Lake Lucina Fits

Who buys well here? The buyer who wants an entry price under the county median and would rather spend on a roof and windows than on a CDD line item — this is mid-century stock, and the inspection list is the real negotiation. It fits the buyer who values a short run to downtown or the Southside over new-construction finishes, and the investor who will verify achievable rents street by street. Who should pass? Anyone unwilling to price insurance before waiving contingencies. Near a lake, two houses a few hundred feet apart can carry very different flood premiums, and that difference belongs in your budget on day one.

Verification, not assumption: pull the flood determination for the exact address from the FEMA Flood Map Service Center, and confirm the school assignment with Duval County Public Schools, since Arlington attendance lines move between streets. The recorded tax bill and any assessments for the parcel are at the Duval County Property Appraiser, and Florida’s homestead and exemption rules are published by the Florida Department of Revenue.